Don The Idea Guy
Ideas that mean business... and MORE business!
  • Home
  • Brainstorming
  • Speaking
  • About DTIG
    • Interviews
  • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Disclosures and Disclaimers
  • Get Free Ideas
Mobile Loyalty vs. Cellular Stalking

Mobile Loyalty vs. Cellular Stalking

Don The Idea Guy September 30, 2014

phone-check-inI recently read an article in AdWeek that posed the question “Is the mobile check-in dead?”  In my opinion I don’t think it’s dead yet, but it might be on life-support.

And bad marketing along with boring retailers put it there.

Once the golden child and shining hope of effective experiential and social affinity marketing, check-in apps seemed to have lost their luster after no single brand emerged as the category leader. Instead they all seemed to multiply like bunnies, with more apps begetting and begatting than all those names in the early chapters of the Old Testament.

I really thought Foursquare had it locked-up.

They were the first and best (and most fun).  Foursquare’s achievement badges and “Mayor” status for the places you visited more than anyone else set the bar incredibly high for any other apps who wanted to take the top spot away from them. They even provided tools and admin accounts to allow super-users to help keep listings accurate, update, and eliminate duplicate locations; as well as providing the means for retail establishments to offer their own check-in specials to users (at no cost to the retailer.)  I think Foursquare’s focus was to grow the user base high enough to sell over-arching sponsorships to larger companies (I saw several Amex campaigns) or to create a paid tier structure to retailers offering specials.

Yelp soon attempted to ride Foursquare’s coattails by adding location check-in to their core review posting tool, but they lacked the fun and innovation and came off as a bad copy.

Best positioned to win the crown would have been Facebook.  They had the existing user base, and when they unveiled Facebook Places I really thought it might result in Facebook buying Foursquare for their fun and engaging gamification execution — but they didn’t. Facebook Places remained dull and unengaging and people just kind of stopped using it.

Sadly, retailers never really came around to using the tools provided by Foursquare — and that is Foursquare’s fault.

Mobile check-in isn’t dead, but bad marketing & boring retailers put it on the critical list.

Click To Tweet

foursquare-check-in-800If Foursquare had held free, local, business building seminars in some of their most promising cities they could have won retailers and restaurants as users by helping them succeed using Foursquare’s tools (and earned themselves client testimonials and success stories while they were at it) which would have won new users into the fold. Instead, Foursquare just seemed to watch their user base atrophy and use their tools less and less.

Out of the blue the folks at Foursquare seemed to launch a new app that solved a problem no one had. Instead of winning users back and breathing excitement back into their core product, they created  new app called Swarm that appeared to be a check-in only app (no reviews, no rankings, no badges, and no Mayors!) It wasn’t fun. It wasn’t engaging. It was Facebook Places without your Friend base.  And then they relaunch Foursquare itself — and I defy anyone to tell me the current purpose of that app.

I was a super-user on the original Foursquare. I had editing and admin access. I held Mayor status at more than 5-10 places at any given time. As Foursquare stopped engaging me (fewer badges, fewer check-in specials), my use of the app declined. When the new Swarm launched I tried it — but it lacked sting. When the new Foursquare app launched and I couldn’t figure out the point of having both apps, I simply ended up deleting both the new Foursquare and Swarm from my phone. I didn’t stop checking-in because I didn’t like it — I stopped because it became boring.

If you read the AdWeek article you’ll see that advertisers are getting more excited about being able to “stalk” mobile users via their GPS and using old-school uninvited and interruption-based advertising by blasting people with a message when they get within a certain distance of their stores. At least with Television, Print, and Radio the ads can have a reciprocal feel (we watch, read, or listen to content and in exchange they can push an advertisement at us), but these cellular stalking ads are completely unbidden. Ironically, many of these ads and offer would have been welcomed had they been shared with us after we checked-in via Foursquare (et al.), the most loyal and active of their consumers — but they’ve decided to forsake the loyal local Foursquare individuals for the appealing-to-advertisers mass audience (which will find these obnoxious and interrupting messages anything but appealing.)

If anyone out there is connected to the folks at Foursquare, I hope you’ll share this article.
I’d love to share some ideas with them.

I believe Foursquare could still make a comeback, but it’s going to take work and a willingness to admit a mistake and move back two squares in order to move forward four squares.

.

Care to share?

  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
The Idea Guy is now The “I-Do” Guy It’s time to Can the “Can I help you?”

Related Posts

letting hot ideas flow

Ideas, Insight

Want hot ideas? Let the tap run.

I’ve written in the past about how I come up with some many good ideas (spoiler alert: it’s because I also come up with so many bad ideas). I’ve also shared how important it is to throw away the first dozen or so ideas you come up with because they’re not going to be especially […]

Care to share?

  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
Who died?

Featured, Ideas, Innovation, Insight, Inspiration, Rant, ThinkLinks

Back from the grave!

Oh, hey. ‘sup? Yeesh. I guess the title of that last blog post turned out to be a little more prophetic than I originally intended! The prior article published on December 31, 2020 was simply meant to signify the last in a series of daily posts that I published through the entire year of 2020 […]

Care to share?

  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
don't lose your head

Ideas, Insight, Rant

Don’t Lose Your Head

There are people who drive you absolutely bonkers (I feel your pain), and make you lose your cool at work. They don’t “do the work” and expect other people to cover for them, they’re constantly running their mouths all day instead of actually doing their work, they play their music through speakers instead of ear […]

Care to share?

  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)


What kinds of ideas are you looking for?

Better Questions = Better Ideas

BUY 100-Whats of Creativity

Cool Stuff For You

free podcast websites

best appointment booking tool

Recent Articles

  • The Ugly Back
  • My Three Words for 2022
  • Want hot ideas? Let the tap run.
  • Back from the grave!
  • The End.

Categories

  • Featured
  • Ideas
  • Innovation
  • Insight
  • Inspiration
  • Rant
  • ThinkLinks
  • Uncategorized

Archives

Tags

action advertising attitude book brainstorming business creativity curiosity customer customer loyalty customers DTIG gitomer goals Ideas Innovation Insight Inspiration kickstart leadership links loyalty marketing media money motivation networking persuasion podcast productivity products projects Rant revenue sales selling service social media speaking success trends web work writing zombies

Idea Guy Projects

  • Big Yellow Sticky
  • Find Your Fries
  • SalesToys
  • Stop Selling At Me!
  • Super Action League

Let’s Connect

Another unusually creative project from Don The Idea Guy
© 2020 - All rights reserved. Do not use content without permission.